Blunt Weapons

Iron (-2)

Silv (=)

Steel (=)

Elv (+2)

Dwar (+4)

Mith (+6)

Adam (+6)

Ebony (+8)

Orc (+10)

Daed (+12)

Mace (1-12)

375

875

500

625

750

625

875

1000

1250

1500

Flail (2-14)

337

875

450

562

675

562

787

900

1125

1350

Staff (1-8)

525

1225

700

875

1050

875

1225

1400

1750

2100

Warhammer (3-18)

412

962

550

687

825

687

962

1100

~1375

1650

Steel is the standard by which weapons are rated.  I have used it as the base and the pluses indicate how much more damage the weapon will do.   Non-steel weapons also have "to hit" adjustments, but I do not know the formula.  Silver is equivalent to steel in terms of damage, but is equivalent to Adamantium in its enchantment potential.  Mithril is superior to Elven in terms of damage, but is equivalent in terms of enchantment potential.  Mithril and Adamantium are equivalent in terms of damage, but Adamantium is clearly superior in its enchantment potential.